The Foundations of Legitimacy A Structural Inquiry Through Negation
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
AbstractThis paper seeks to examine the concept of “legitimacy” through a de-rhetoricized and de-authoritized analytical approach. By systematically dismantling common surface-level concepts (such as outcomes, procedures, and rights), it returns to the foundational conditions of human existence (survival, interaction, and stability). On this basis, it proposes a two-tier definition: an abstract ultimate criterion (“the continuation of beauty”) and a concrete, human-operational standard (survival, dignity, and rules). Building on this framework, the paper further develops a set of negative criteria to identify false or invalid claims of legitimacy. Ultimately, it argues that understanding legitimacy lies not in constructing a perfect definition, but in establishing non-negotiable boundaries.________________________________________I. Introduction“Legitimacy” is commonly used to describe the justification of authority, yet its meaning is often entangled with history, culture, and power narratives. Traditional interpretations—such as:• Whether outcomes are good• Whether procedures are proper• Whether rights are respectedshare a common flaw:they are susceptible to manipulation, reinterpretation, and fabrication.Thus, a “truth-oriented” inquiry into legitimacy requires abandoning these unstable mid-level concepts and seeking a deeper, more resilient foundation.________________________________________II. Foundational Reduction: From Rhetoric to StructureThrough deconstruction and reductio reasoning, the problem can be reduced to two irreducible levels:1. Fact of survival: individuals reject their own destruction2. Structure of interaction: humans exist within repeated, long-term interactionsFrom this, the following can be derived:• Arbitrary deprivation of life destroys the possibility of cooperation• Arbitrary domination destroys trust and stability• Unpredictable rules render long-term action meaninglessThese are not moral claims, but structural constraints.________________________________________III. A Two-Tier Structure of Definition(1) Ultimate Criterion (Transcendent Standpoint)Legitimacy ultimately points to the “continuation of beauty.”Here, “beauty” is not aesthetic, but refers to:• Non-self-destructive states of existence• Sustainable structures• Orders capable of accumulation and developmentThis level is abstract, global, and terminal—functioning as an “external evaluative standard.”________________________________________(2) Human-Level Criterion (Operational Layer)Translating the ultimate criterion into human terms yields:Legitimacy is a judgment of whether a form of rule avoids arbitrary destruction, arbitrary domination, and maintains predictable rules.Concretely:1. Survival constraint: no arbitrary deprivation of life2. Dignity constraint: no arbitrary domination of individuals3. Rule constraint: systems must exhibit predictabilityTogether, these form the minimal conditions for a non-self-destructive civilization.________________________________________IV. The Negative Method: Boundaries of LegitimacyRather than defining what is legitimate, it is more effective to determine what is necessarily illegitimate.This yields the following negative rules:(1) Arbitrary destruction of life→ undermines the basis of existence → illegitimate(2) Arbitrary domination of others→ undermines cooperative structure → illegitimate(3) Unpredictable rules→ undermines long-term action → illegitimateTherefore:Any system that crosses any of these boundaries, regardless of its claims, lacks legitimacy.________________________________________V. Discussion: From Truth to BoundariesThis analysis suggests:• Legitimacy resists complete positive definition• Yet it can be indirectly established through structural constraintsThis approach avoids:• Moral rhetoric• Authority-based justification• Subjective preferenceand instead rests on:the conditions required for the continued existence and development of civilization.________________________________________VI. ConclusionLegitimacy is not a lofty ideal, but a set of structural conditions preventing human self-destruction.Its ultimate form may be expressed as:a judgment of whether a system of rule preserves the fundamental structures that allow human continuity.Yet we must also acknowledge:Although truth cannot be directly seen, described, or transmitted, we should not abandon the pursuit of the glory of God.This pursuit does not lead to absolute answers, but to the continual refinement of boundaries.________________________________________VII. Summary PropositionsThe entire argument may be reduced to three propositions:1. Legitimacy cannot rely on rhetorical definitions2. Legitimacy can be indirectly grounded in structural conditions3. The practice of legitimacy depends primarily on negative boundaries________________________________________Keywords: legitimacy, negative method, Nash equilibrium, right to survival, dignity, civilizational stability
Fields of Study & Subjects
Political Philosophy and Ethics
Philosophical Ethics and Theory
Philosophy and Social Theory
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 26 March 2026
- Language
- EN
- Document type
- Preprint