Evaluation as Conjecture: Reflective Judgment and the Ontological Ground of Rational Agency
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
This paper argues that the operation occurring inside the deliberative interval -- between theopening of suspension and the closure of commitment -- is irreducible to computational selection.Against functionalist accounts that treat intra-interval processing as optimization over a givenspace, I demonstrate that human evaluation is constitutively conjectural: the agent submits ahypothesis to friction with an exteriority it does not control, and judges the result without apre-given rule. This structure -- conjecture, friction, judgment -- is established through aphenomenological analysis of three domains (engineering, science, art) exhibiting a gradient fromexternal criterion to emergentcriterion, and through a formal argumentderivingevaluation-as-conjecture from the indigence established in a companion paper. Threearguments against the functionalist reduction follow: the friction argument (evaluation istrans-spatial, not intra-spatial), the emergent criterion argument (evaluation generates itsevaluative standard through the act of evaluating, which no optimization procedure can do), andtheirretractability argument (human judgment constitutes the agent who issues it, making itexistentially non-retractable in a way no computational output can be). The paper concludes thatevaluation is the second of three ontological operations constituting free agency --Suspensionopens the interval, Evaluation fills it, Signature closes it -- and that thecorrectcharacterization of evaluation has direct consequences for AI governance, legal dueprocess, and the epistemology of trust in automated systems.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Philosophical Ethics and Theory
Philosophy and Theoretical Science
Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 28 March 2026
- Language
- EN