Projection-Induced Determinism: Observer-Imposed Compression in Neurobiological Models of Behavior (A CRTI-Based Analysis)

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Bernd von Mallinckrodt
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Low-dimensional models do not reveal simplicity — they create it. This paper introduces Projection-Induced Determinism (PID), showing how observer-imposed dimensional reduction generates apparent causal order by discarding the dimensions that carry uncertainty. This preprint introduces Projection-Induced Determinism (PID), a formal mechanism by which low-dimensional measurement models generate the appearance of causal closure in high-dimensional systems. Focusing on neurobiological models of behavior, we show that commonly used neurotransmitter-based representations (e.g., dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine, GABA, glutamate) do not reveal an intrinsically low-dimensional causal structure, but instead impose dimensional reduction through the observer’s choice of measurement basis. We formalize this process as an explicit projection operator M: \mathbb{R}^n \to \mathbb{R}^m with n \gg m, demonstrating that dimensions orthogonal to the measurement basis—containing structured uncertainty and adaptive degrees of freedom—are systematically discarded. This leads to PID: an epistemic artifact in which models appear deterministic not because they capture the system’s causal structure, but because they remove the dimensions that carry uncertainty. PID is embedded within the Compression–Response Transition Index (CRTI) framework, where adaptive capacity R and structural compression \Phi are modeled as coupled dynamical variables. We show that projection induces a systematic bias in the viability estimate T = R / \Phi, such that observed adaptive capacity R_{obs} is bounded by the true adaptive capacity R_{true}, leading to potential misinterpretation of system stability and intervention effects. The analysis yields three central implications: Neurobiological explanation — Neurotransmitter-based models provide projected representations of behavior, not full causal accounts of the nervous system. Pharmacological intervention — Treatments targeting projected variables may fail to engage orthogonal adaptive dimensions, contributing to relapse dynamics. Model selection — Predictive accuracy within a fixed measurement basis is insufficient to validate causal models; robustness across multiple projection bases is required. The accompanying cover illustration provides a visual formalization of PID, depicting the transformation of a high-dimensional dynamical manifold into a low-dimensional set of ordered observables, with “ghost dimensions” marking the loss of structured uncertainty at the projection boundary. While neurobiology serves as the primary application domain, PID is a general phenomenon applicable to any high-dimensional system analyzed through low-dimensional projections, including ecological, economic, and organizational systems. This work contributes to the CRTI research program by extending its formalism to measurement-induced epistemic effects and by providing a unified framework linking dimensional reduction, adaptive capacity, and apparent determinism. Primary Keywords Projection-Induced Determinism Observer-Imposed Compression CRTI Framework Dimensional Reduction Complex Systems Secondary Keywords Systems Neuroscience Neurotransmitter Models Adaptive Capacity Structural Compression Viability Ratio Epistemology of Measurement Extended / Cross-Disciplinary Keywords Dynamical Systems Model Selection High-Dimensional Systems Causal Inference Early Warning Signals Systems Biology Computational Neuroscience

Fields of Study & Subjects

Philosophy of Biology and Scientific Explanation Complex Systems and Dynamics Philosophy and Theoretical Science

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
28 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint