On Critical Gaps in the Proposed Counterexample to Viterbo's Volume-Capacity Conjecture
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
We present a detailed critical analysis of the recent paper by Haim-Kislev and Ostrover claiming a counterexample to Viterbo's volume-capacity conjecture. We identify several substantial logical gaps in the proof of their central Proposition, which asserts that the Ekeland--Hofer--Zehnder capacity of the Lagrangian product of two pentagons equals the $T^\circ$-length of the diagonal 2-bounce trajectory. Specifically, we show that: (1) the combinatorial classification of non-translatable 3-vertex polygonal curves in the pentagon is incomplete and unjustified; (2) the identification of active support vertices of $h_T$ across deformation families is not exhaustive; (3) the reduction from 3-bounce to 2-bounce trajectories via the triangle inequality does not preserve admissibility in the constrained minimization problem; and (4) the claimed symmetry reduction conflates distinct geometric configurations under an anisotropic, non-symmetric norm. We further demonstrate that the margin by which the systolic ratio allegedly exceeds unity is so small ($\approx 4.7\%$) that any of these individual gaps, if resulting in even a minor correction to the capacity value, would invalidate the counterexample entirely. We conclude that the proof of the central Proposition, and consequently of the main Theorem, is not logically sound as presented.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Geometric and Algebraic Topology
Geometric Analysis and Curvature Flows
Algebraic Geometry and Number Theory
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 28 March 2026
- Language
- EN
- Document type
- Preprint