Applicability Boundary Doctrine: External Admissibility and Continuation Legitimacy in High-Consequence and Decision-Bearing Systems
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
This publication defines the Applicability Boundary Doctrine: a formal framework for identifying the point at which operational continuation loses legitimacy despite nominal correctness, procedural compliance, technical control, or apparent validation. The doctrine applies to systems whose decisions, recommendations, classifications, transitions, or automated continuations can produce material real-world consequences. This includes autonomous systems, semi-autonomous systems, decision-support systems, regulated systems, and other high-consequence human–machine or institutionally governed environments operating under contractual, operational, evidentiary, supervisory, or legal constraints. Its central distinction is between behavioral correctness within a mode and the applicability of that mode to the conditions it purports to govern. The doctrine introduces external admissibility as a separate requirement for defensible continuation, and defines the conditions under which outputs may acquire operational or normative significance only within an accountable mandate, identifiable authority structure, and bounded scope of responsibility. Critically, admissibility must remain non-derivable from the execution path itself and must remain defensible under external audit, regulatory scrutiny, supervisory review, insurance assessment, and post-incident analysis. It does not validate decisions.It defines when validation claims, authority claims, observational consistency, or internal governance no longer suffice as legitimate grounds for materially consequential action. This release continues an authored doctrinal framework developed prior to this publication. Earlier versions, canonical site publication, and independently timestamped public records support continuity of authorship and development history. This publication is intentionally limited to the doctrinal and evidentiary layer. It does not disclose implementation mechanisms, enforcement architectures, executable design structures, algorithms, or operational procedures. Its purpose is to establish a public, citable framework for continuation legitimacy, applicability loss, accountable mandate, and decision defensibility across high-consequence and decision-bearing environments.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Safety Systems Engineering in Autonomy
Ethics and Social Impacts of AI
Digitalization
Law
and Regulation
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 30 March 2026
- Language
- EN