SUBSCRIPTION SUBJECTS, IN THE NAME OF DEMOCRACY, LET US ALL UNITE! A NEW POINT OF DEMOCRATIC TRANSFORMATION FOR SOCIAL MEDIA

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Paul Geyer
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Meta and Snapchat announced that paying members on their platform can have an ad-free experience, without their data being processed for advertising (Meta 2024; Lomas 2023). Due to this seemingly slight economic shift, this article argues that EU-subscription-users embody a new source of democratic transformation for social media. Subscription users possess influential economic and political power, since the subscription fee becomes the main source of economic valorisation, instead of data extraction. Consequently, subscription users have newfound economic, political and social opportunities to pressure social media companies. This article advances subscription users as a new source of social power and democratic transformation by reconsidering the subscription fee as a potential public thing and a point of collectivisation. Section One explores earlier attempts to democratically transform social media through state regulations, better education, ownership of social media, the structural interactions of platforms (interoperable), and public resistance to the exploitative data-extracting practices of big tech companies. The aim of this section is to show the range of thought for conceptualising different ways of democratically transforming social media and to highlight that subscription users, as a form of democratic transformation, is a new direction in these debates. Section Two develops the theoretical framework of this democratic potential. The theoretical arguments are derived from Erik Olin Wright’s ‘socialist hybrid’ and Bonnie Honig’s ‘public things’. Wright’s socialist hybrid offers a framework of utilising social power to bend capitalist apparatus to the demands of the social. I argue that EU-subscription social media users can exploit this socialist hybrid logic as they occupy a position in the subscription economic sphere that allows them to apply this newfound social power. Crucially, Wright’s approach allows for capitalist frameworks to remain but reconstitutes power relations towards a social power. Bonnie Honig’s use of public things argues that objects or concepts in society can interpellate people into democratic subjects (parks, schools, public transportation etc). This idea will be applied to the subscription fee in order to demonstrate that it can be transformed into a public thing experience. Currently, the paying of the fee is an individual experience; whereas, through Honig’s public things perspective the fee can be seen as public thing because it enables public oversight. Section Three develops the case study of Watcher, a YouTube channel, as an example of this newfound power/potential of democratic transformation. Watcher attempted to shift to a subscription model and stop all free content being produced on YouTube. This caused outrage amongst their community and the YouTube community in general. The Watcher community acted in concert to pressure Watcher into changing their model and keeping content available on their YouTube channel. This case, I argue, acts as a representative one of the potential power of subscribers: the fee, or the willingness to pay the fee, became a political question. The Watcher community also became more influential, in an economic sense because it was the users’ willingness to pay the fee that was the foundation of the economic model. Whilst there are limitations (discussed in the following section), the Watcher example is a useful reference point to demonstrate the potential power EU subscription users possess. Section Four explores the tensions that arises from utilising subscription users as a form of democratic transformation. First, is it reasonable to compare the mobilisation of a single YouTube channel to the complexity of mobilising users across the EU? Second, the Watcher audience rejected the subscription package; therefore, is it not contradictory for the article to persist with advocating for the democratic potential of subscription users? Third, does the fee not contradict Honig’s idea of a Public Thing? Fourth, what about the role of users who do not pay or cannot pay, are these users not excluded from this democratic transformation? These tensions and questions will be examined to contextualise the potential power and role of the subscription users © 2026 Euricom, Published by NewtonGate

Fields of Study & Subjects

Social Media and Politics Digital Economy and Work Transformation Political Theory and Democracy

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN