The Constitution Axiom

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Gregory Caldwell Beier
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Abstract This paper proposes that coordination-dependent structures are constituted by observation, not merely described by it, and identifies a falsifiable empirical test distinguishing this claim from the standard epistemic alternative. The standard view predicts that exogenous withdrawal of observation (e.g., analyst coverage loss following MiFID II) produces noisier estimates of an unchanged firm. The Constitution Axiom predicts that the firm's coordination-dependent operating metrics themselves degrade. Existing evidence (Derrien and Kecskés, 2013; Kelly and Ljungqvist, 2012) documents real operational changes following exogenous coverage loss, consistent with the Constitution Axiom but not yet discriminating between the two views. The distinguishing prediction - that operational degradation scales with the Beierspace fraction b rather than with information asymmetry - has not been tested. This paper identifies the test. Running it is future work. The formal statement is Axiom 0 of Coordination Science: for any structure with Beierspace fraction b > 0, the covariance matrix decomposes as Sigma(t) = (1 - b) * Sigma_E + b * F(O(t)), where Sigma_E is the physically-determined component (independent of observation), F is a continuous linear functional mapping aggregate observation to coordination structure, and O(t) is the observation process of finite agents. The Constitution Condition requires that coordination-dependent structure on any dimension decays to zero when observation on that dimension is withdrawn. The Cross-Dimensional Constitution Condition requires that coordination-dependent interactions between dimensions can exist only when some agency's observation spans both. Of the five axioms of the Prolegomena, one (Observation-Maintenance) is contained in Axiom 0 by inclusion, and two (Irreducible Heterogeneity and Reflexivity) are derived from it under specified conditions. Two (Bounded Capacity and Compression Inevitability) follow from finitude alone and do not require the Constitution Axiom. The six theorems of the Prolegomena (Excess Distortion, Dissipation, Goodhart, Beier Factorial, Phase Transition, and the Grossman-Stiglitz Resolution) follow from the five axioms through existing proofs. Fom the Prolegomena to the Unification of Economics, Computer Science, Mathematics, and Physics by Gregory Caldwell Beier (forthcoming 2026). Keywords: Coordination Science, observation-constituted reality, Beierspace fraction, covariance decomposition, rate-distortion theory, scalar compression, institutional design, disclosure commons, analyst coverage, MiFID II, information asymmetry

Fields of Study & Subjects

Complex Systems and Dynamics Economic Theory and Institutions Complex Systems and Time Series Analysis

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
30 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint