Theorem 162 (PUH): The PPC Theia Hypothesis — The Moon Was Formed by a Neptune-Mass Primordial Planck Core, Planet X Is the Same Object Still Orbiting the Solar System, and It Is Coming Back
Summary
No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.
Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.Abstract
Abstract:The standard giant impact hypothesis proposes that a Mars-sized body called Theia struck the proto-Earth 4.5 billion years ago, forming the Moon. This model has a persistent unresolved problem: the Earth and Moon have essentially identical isotopic compositions (oxygen, titanium, tungsten), whereas a separate impactor body should have left a distinct isotopic signature in the Moon. No satisfactory resolution exists in the standard framework.This paper proposes that Theia was not a rocky planetoid but a Primordial Planck Core (PPC) of Neptune-to-Uranus mass (–17 ). A PPC is pure compressed geometry at Planck density with no chemical composition — no protons, neutrons, or electrons. When the PPC transited the proto-Earth in approximately 10.6 minutes, it exerted a tidal acceleration of m/s on Earth’s mantle — 34 times Earth’s own surface gravity — imparting a velocity kick of km/s to surface material, 19 times Earth’s escape velocity. Only Earth material was ejected. The PPC left zero isotopic signature. The isotopic identity problem is solved exactly.The PPC lost only 11.7% of its momentum to Earth and continued on its solar orbit. Planet X — the proposed but optically undetected Neptune-mass outer solar system perturber inferred from trans-Neptunian object orbit clustering (Batygin & Brown 2016) — is identified as this same PPC. A PPC has Planck-scale physical size: zero reflected sunlight, zero thermal emission. It is gravitationally present but optically invisible, directly explaining the failure of decades of optical Planet X searches.Seven independent observations are satisfied simultaneously: the Earth-Moon isotopic identity, the absence of a Theia remnant, the Moon’s upper-mantle composition, the Moon’s lack of an iron core, Planet X’s inferred Neptune-scale mass, Planet X’s optical invisibility, and the predicted orbital inclination of – derived from the impact geometry that also set Earth’s axial tilt of .The PPC has completed approximately 243,000 orbits of the solar system since the Moon-forming impact, returning to perihelion every $\approx$18,500 years. In its current estimated orbit (semi-major axis $\sim$700 AU, eccentricity $\sim$0.6) the perihelion is at $\sim$280 AU — well beyond Neptune. The orbit appears to have retreated from the inner solar system over 4.5 billion years of planetary perturbations. However, three orbital scenarios are identified — safe retreat, uncertain chaotic oscillation, and alarming return — and the determination of which applies requires precise Planet X orbital elements that have not yet been measured.The paper concludes that finding Planet X and computing its precise orbital history is not merely an astronomical exercise. The object that made the Moon is still here. Finding it precisely is urgent.Priority timestamp: March 30, 2026.
Fields of Study & Subjects
Astro and Planetary Science
Stellar
planetary
and galactic studies
History and Developments in Astronomy
Publication details
- Journal / source
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Publication date
- 31 March 2026
- Language
- EN
- Document type
- Preprint