Static Permissibility in Dynamic Normative Environments: Dynamic Classification Failure as a Structural Property of Institutional Computation

Read full text
Authors: Ignacio Adrián LERER
Cited by: 2

Abstract

This paper argues that computational systems deployed in consequence-bearing institutional contexts inherit an often implicit assumption: that the normative conditions under which an action was classified as permissible remain stable until the action is executed. The paper formalizes the failure of that assumption as Dynamic Classification Failure (DCF): reliance on a stale permissibility label in a normative environment that has changed between classification and consequence. The analysis defines DCF as a state-transition failure in institutional computation, distinguishes it from authorization defects, implementation errors, and design failures, and situates it within the Generalized Intentionality Mismatch Theorem. It derives necessary conditions for detecting and preventing DCF and connects the formal model to legal and regulatory frameworks for automated institutional action, runtime admissibility, AI governance, and agentic systems.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Ethics and Social Impacts of AI Multi-Agent Systems and Negotiation Law AI and Intellectual Property

Publication details

Journal / source
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Publication date
1 July 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint