Occupied Plurality: On the Family, the Community, and the We That Does Not Multiply the I

Read full text
Authors: Oscar Gaitan
Cited by: 6
References: 4

Abstract

This essay extends the Gaitan Topology from the ontology of the individual to the ontology of relation. Beginning with the birth of a child, it asks how several occupied crossing points can enter a genuine relation without becoming a composite substance. It rejects both an additive model, in which persons merely accumulate, and a composite model, in which family or community becomes a fourth super-person. Instead, it introduces the “between” as a real but dependent relational reality: irreducible to either person, yet incapable of existing independently of their mutual occupancy. The essay then revisits relational density and distinguishes four fundamental forms of created plurality: Legion, family and community, the crowd, and the algorithmic aggregate. It concludes by clarifying Topological Relativity: reality itself does not multiply according to observers; the event remains one while relations to it differ. Thus occupied plurality does not multiply the first-person singular but makes possible a genuine “we” without destroying the “I.”

Fields of Study & Subjects

Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy Critical Realism in Sociology Embodied and Extended Cognition

Publication details

Journal / source
PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation)
Publication date
1 September 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Book