Why even a rational devil could be righteous under a Kantian account of right?

Read full text
Authors: Gehad Marcon Bark
Cited by: 0
References: 14

Abstract

This paper focuses on Kant’s Towards Perpetual Peace famous statement according to which the problem of the State can be solved even for a race of devils. Its first aim is to show that coercion exerted via positive laws is pivotal to the understanding of Kant’s main thesis regarding this nation of devils and the correspondent accomplishment of reason’s ends through the “mechanical course of nature” (ZeF, AA 08, p. 367). According to this reviewed version of Kant’s hypothesis, however, by refraining from violating the laws of a republican State out of self-interest, a devil would have to be taken as genuinely righteous according to rational principles. To make sense of this statement, Kant’s hypothesis shall be developed and interpreted as coherently enclosing a general thesis regarding the normativity of right and its source on the external use of free choice independently of each agent’s moral virtue.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Kantian Philosophy and Modern Interpretations Philosophical Ethics and Theory Political Philosophy and Ethics

Publication details

Journal / source
DoisPontos
Volume
22
Issue
3
Publication date
23 February 2026
Language
EN