A PROVA DIGITAL E O PRINCÍPIO NEMO TENETUR SE DETEGERE: A COLISÃO DE DIREITOS NA ATUAÇÃO DO MINISTÉRIO PÚBLICO BRASILEIRO

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: LEANDRO SANTOS MEDEIROS
Cited by: 0
References: 2

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Technological advances have made digital evidence central to criminal proceedings, particularly with the widespread use of end-to-end encryption and password or biometric protection of devices. This context creates a legal dilemma: on one side, the prosecutorial duty of the Public Prosecutor’s Office to investigate and uphold public order; on the other, the defendant’s fundamental right not to produce evidence against oneself, enshrined in the nemo tenetur se detegere principle. This article examines the collision between these fundamental rights, discussing whether refusal to provide passwords to electronic devices falls under the protection against self-incrimination, and whether a legal distinction exists between providing a password (an act of knowledge) and unlocking a device through biometrics (a physical act). The paper also analyzes the current case law of the Brazilian Supreme Federal Court and Superior Court of Justice, still marked by divergences, along with comparative perspectives from the United States, Germany, and the European Court of Human Rights. The methodology combines doctrinal, jurisprudential, and comparative law approaches, highlighting constitutional foundations for personal data protection and privacy rights. Legitimate investigative alternatives available to the Public Prosecutor’s Office are explored, such as advanced forensic techniques, international cooperation, and the use of open-source intelligence, provided that proportionality and human dignity are respected. The study concludes that technology poses new challenges for criminal proceedings but cannot justify the erosion of constitutional safeguards. The distinction between “knowing” and “being” (passwords versus biometrics) emerges as a significant criterion, though greater jurisprudential uniformity and potential legislative regulation are required. Balancing investigative efficiency with fundamental rights is essential to ensure the legitimacy of state action in the digital sphere.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Criminal Law and Evidence Education Law and Society European Criminal Justice and Data Protection

Publication details

Journal / source
INTERNATIONAL INTEGRALIZE SCIENTIFIC
Volume
6
Issue
56
Publication date
27 February 2026
Language
EN