Nonlinear Impacts of Herbivory on Plants Explain the Herbivory Paradox

Herbivores strongly shape plant ecology and evolution. Yet plants typically sustain low, tolerable levels of damage, raising the question of how herbivory influences plant biology despite often weak fitness effects. Analyzing 1,145 datasets of the effects of damage on fitness for 103 plant species worldwide, we show that nonlinear tolerance to damage is one explanation for this paradoxical contradiction. Plants are tolerant of low levels of damage, but infrequent, severe damage levels disproportionately reduce plant fitness. Models incorporating nonlinear tolerance suggest that disproportionate tolerance to low levels of damage stabilizes population dynamics and promotes coevolutionary feedback with herbivores. Pervasive nonlinear tolerance shows consistent patterns across environmental gradients, may alter the stability of food webs, and may explain why herbivory matters despite the world being green.