Assessing the impact of parental linear gene normalization on the performance of statistical models for circular RNA differential expression analysis

Abstract Background Circular RNAs (circRNAs) emerged as promising non-invasive cancer biomarkers due to their stability, abundance in body fluids, and regulatory potential. However, circRNA differential expression analysis (DEA) remains challenging, largely owing to lack of consensus on important preprocessing strategies such as filtering and normalization. While well-established bulk RNA-sequencing frameworks are commonly applied to circRNA data, newer approaches such as CIRI-DE (part of CIRI3 suite) integrate both linear and circular transcript information to improve detection. Despite developments, an assessment of these integrative strategies is lacking, and the critical impact of filtering on DEA model performance has not been comprehensively evaluated. Results In this study, we evaluated the impact of multiple normalization and filtering strategies on circRNA DEA using five experimental datasets, including two in-house blood platelet sets and semi-parametric simulated in silico datasets. Our results emphasize the importance of selecting an appropriate filtering threshold, as overly lenient filtering substantially reduced model performance across datasets. We found edgeR’s filterByExpr() strategy particularly effective in handling zero counts in circRNA data, while also generating the most reliable results across most datasets. Furthermore, by incorporating linear and circular information as described in CIRI-DE, most methods identified a higher number of differentially expressed (DE) circRNAs compared to circular counts alone. Notably, circRNAs identified by both CIRI-DE and the modified bulk RNA-sequencing pipelines showed substantial overlap. Conclusion Our findings demonstrate that automated filtering combined with linear-aware normalization significantly enhances the sensitivity and reproducibility of circRNA DEA, providing a standardized framework for more reliable biomarker discovery in transcriptomic research.