Authoritarian Narratives of Silence Legitimation: Governmental Tactics and the Use of Crisis Discourse in the 2024~2025 State-Medical Profession Conflict

View at publisher Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: HyeRin Roh
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The Korean physicians’ collective action in the 2024~2025 state-medical profession conflict failed to secure institutional or political gains. Rather than responding ad hoc, the government deliberately mobilized a set of pre-prepared strategic tactics that constrained physicians’ resistance and legitimized silence. While prior studies have examined power, symbols, emotions, and meaning-making as separate elements, they have not sufficiently analyzed how the state combined these elements and organizes them into techniques of governance. This gap matters because, without recognizing these strategies, many accounts interpret silence as an individual or collective choice rather than as an effect produced by state power. The end of medicine does not arrivie with the collapse of the healthcare system, but when physicians‘ practical knowledge can no longer speak in public deliberation. This study addresses this gap by proposing an analytical framework, the Authoritarian Narratives of Silence Legitimation. In this study, authoritarian refers to a mode of governance through which the state maintains democratic forms while actively narrowing the scope of deliberation, not to a regime type. To construct the framework, the study reconstructs critical analytical insights from statelevel discursive materials spanning 2024 to 2025. The analysis proceeds in three steps. First, the study defines practical knowledge in medicine and traces its philosophical foundations, professional lineage, and political vulnerability. Second, the study identifies five narrative tactics through which the state redefined the conditions of legitimate speech: (1) creation of justification, (2) stigmatization and judicialization of dissent, (3) heroization of the state, (4) scientific-expert legitimation, and (5) staged democratic legitimacy. Third, the study analyzes the state combined thse tactics to reshape the rules of policy deliberation and to predefine which forms of knowledge could legitimately speak. This process excluded practical knowledge from public contestation. This framework enables researchers to analyze how states actively transform silence into a rational and moral stance. Although this study grounds the framework in the 2024~2025 Korean case, further research can apply and refine it across other state-professional conflicts and broader arenas of public policy contention.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Foucault Power and Ethics Cultural and political discourse analysis Political Theory and Democracy

Publication details

Volume
1
Issue
1
Pages
21–39
Publication date
28 February 2026
Language
EN