Volunteer Motivation: Enlistment Motivations of German and Australian Soldiers who fought in the Battle of Crete

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Richard Travers
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

The study addresses the question: what motivates young men to volunteer for dangerous military service? It is a comparative study of 2,573 German and Australian soldiers who fought a battle at Rethymnon on the Greek island of Crete in May 1941. Historians have traditionally attempted to answer questions of enlistment motivation by analysing reasons for volunteering given by returned men later in life. Reasons given in those circumstances are often unreliable, and give a misleading picture of the reasons why men volunteer. The thesis of the study is that motivational patterns are not to be found in lists of reasons given by soldiers later in life, but in an examination of the social forces that shaped the lives of the soldiers down to the moment of their volunteering – the forces that instilled values in them as young men, that created expectations of their behaviour and shaped the way they, as a group, acted. The study follows 1,307 German and 1,266 Australian soldiers who volunteered to serve in World War II from birth to volunteering, analysing social forces in their communities that shaped their decisions to volunteer. The study has identified deep-seated social pressures that motivated their volunteering. The social pressures that motivated the German soldiers in the study to volunteer were the pressures to make Germany great again, to restore German pride, to erase the shame of defeat in World War I and to undo the humiliations of the Treaty of Versailles. The social pressures that motivated the Australian soldiers in the study to volunteer were the pressures to emulate the diggers of the 1st AIF in resisting German aggression and to uphold the values of the British Empire. The pressures were seen in family and community expectations of the soldiers’ behaviour, in generational forces, in memories of things past (especially World War I), in emotions, especially the emotions of nation, Reich and Empire, and in responses to propaganda and the urgings of politicians, statesmen and demagogues. The pressures were so strong that the decisions of the soldiers in the study to volunteer for war service were logical, coherent with their values, and natural expressions of their self-esteem. In the infinity of individual circumstances, however, each man was influenced by personal factors that co-existed with the motivations that came from social pressures. These may have counted in favour of volunteering, as in a family tradition of military service, or the need to escape a bad situation at home, or they may have counted against volunteering, as in the need to care for a wife and children, or to run the family farm. Another factor to be considered was the state of the war, and the severity of the crisis it posed for the nation. Each man weighed factors like these in balance when deciding whether to volunteer.

Fields of Study & Subjects

World Wars: History Literature and Impact Military history and social perspectives Australian History and Society

Publication details

Journal / source
Research Online (University of Wollongong)
Publication date
25 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis