Enhancing Awareness and Understanding of Predatory Journals: A Delphi-Validated Educational Video.

Read full text
Authors: Alessandro Martinino, Victoria Zecchin Ferrara, Justin Ho, Rodolfo J. Oviedo, Des C Winter, Marlies P. Schijven, Jennifer Isherwood, Mithi Ahmed-Richards, Steven D. Wexner, Raul Rosenthal, Sjaak Pouwels, Frank W.J.M. Smeenk
Cited by: 0

Abstract

Introduction: Predatory journals threaten academic integrity, highlighting the need to educate young researchers on identifying and avoiding them. This study aims to develop and validate an educational video to raise awareness of predatory journals and equip future scholars with essential publishing skills. Methodology: Between August and November 2024, two Delphi processes were carried out. The first involved validation of the video script, incorporating feedback from 10 experts in academia and publishing. The second focused on refining the audiovisual components with input from two graphic and communication designers. Consensus was established at a threshold of 100% agreement. Additionally, 15 young researchers participated to ensure the video was tailored to the target audience. Results: The final video was produced following a three-round Delphi process to validate the script and a two-round process to finalize the audiovisual features. Validation by the target audience contributed to enhancing the video's quality and ensuring it was well-tailored to the end users. The final video has a duration of 10 minutes and 42 seconds. Conclusion: This study developed and validated an educational video to raise awareness of predatory journals. Refined through a rigorous Delphi process and audience feedback, the video meets high standards of clarity and usability, offering a valuable tool for young researchers. Future evaluations will assess its effectiveness.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Publishing and Scholarly Communication Academic integrity and plagiarism Academic Writing and Publishing

Publication details

Journal / source
PubMed
Volume
177
Issue
1
Pages
12–22
Publication date
12 January 2026
Language
EN