Old Gutnish revisited

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Claire Graf
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This thesis presents a comprehensive reassessment of Old Gutnish, a North Germanic variety historically spoken on Gotland, and its position within the North Germanic dialect continuum. Recognising Old Gutnish as a language from a socio-political perspective, the study critically examines its linguistic features and seeks to clarify its status within the North Germanic family, using both traditional philological approaches and innovative quantitative methods. Part I lays the conceptual groundwork, defining the research questions, terminology, and methodological approaches. The thesis deliberately focuses on runic inscriptions and manuscript witnesses while excluding modern dialect data and place names due to their higher degrees of uncertainty. Part II employs traditional linguistic methods to analyse the phonological, morphological, syntactic, and lexical features of both runic and manuscript Old Gutnish. The findings reveal that Old Gutnish, while exhibiting certain conservative traits and peripheral innovations, behaves largely as expected for a fringe variety within Old East Norse. The study also revisits and ultimately rejects older claims of a special connection between Old Gutnish and Gothic. Additionally, the idea of a Scandinavian-wide runic koiné is critically assessed and argued against. Part III evaluates various quantitative and modelling approaches, including phylogenetic and network-based methods, and critically assesses their limitations in the context of the fragmentary and uncertain runic dataset. Given these challenges, the thesis adopts a weighted corpus approach, combining explicit modelling of uncertainty with a carefully curated and feature-focused dataset, ensuring that the linguistic ambiguities are integrated into the analysis rather than dismissed. Part IV reflects on the broader implications of these findings, arguing that Old Gutnish's position at the linguistic periphery is typical for such varieties, exhibiting both prolonged retentions and idiosyncratic developments. The thesis concludes that Old Gutnish should be viewed as a peripheral Old Swedish variety, and that decisions about splitting languages from continua are always heuristic, shaped by scholarly consensus rather than objective thresholds. By integrating traditional philological analysis with quantitative modelling, this thesis offers new methodological perspectives for dealing with small, uncertain data in historical linguistics, and proposes a more nuanced approach to understanding linguistic variation at the margins of dialect continua.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Linguistics and language evolution Linguistic Variation and Morphology Viking Age and Medieval Scandinavia

Publication details

Journal / source
University of Edinburgh
Publication date
26 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis