Muhammed Hâdî Marifet ve Muhammed Hüseyin ez-Zehebî’nin İsrâiliyata Yaklaşımlarındaki Mezhebî Yönelimleri

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Muhammet Çol
Cited by: 0
References: 6

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This study examines the isrā'īliyyāt narratives originating from the Ahl al-Kitab, which were utilized in a controlled manner since the early period to elucidate the mubhamāt of the Qur'an, alongside the critical and exclusionary approaches developed against these traditions in the modern era.The primary objective is to analyze and compare the approaches of the Shi'i scholar Muhammad Hadi Ma'rifat (d.2007), known for his negative stance toward the use of such information in exegesis and Muhammad Husayn al-Dhahabi (d.1977), who represents the Sunni framework.The central problem addresses the methodological divergences and distinct mental frameworks regarding the phenomenon of isrā'īliyyāt between these two authors, who otherwise appear to follow a similar line in terms of style and content.Employing qualitative content analysis and the comparative method, the research contrasts Ma'rifat's normative presuppositions centered on the Imamate with al-Dhahabi's balanced and classificatory approach.Findings indicate that Ma'rifat adopts an absolute rejectionist attitude, arguing that isrā'īliyyāt holds no legitimacy in exegesis.Within this framework, it is observed that he harshly criticizes the isrā'īliyyāt reports in Sunni exegeses, while defending similar reports found in works close to the Ahl al-Bayt, and even adopts a divisive stance among the sahaba regarding this issue.In contrast to Ma'rifat's categorical rejection, al-Dhahabi adopts a more flexible methodology; instead of entirely excluding isrā'īliyyāt, he references their controlled use during the sahaba period and subjects these narrations to a threefold classification of "acceptance, rejection, and tawaqquf".Consequently, it is concluded that while both approaches are influenced by sectarian tendencies, Imamate-centered theological presuppositions are strictly determinative in Ma'rifat's stance.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Qur’anic Interpretation Studies Islamic Thought and Society Studies Historical and Linguistic Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
Turkish Studies - Comparative Religious Studies
Volume
Volume 21 Issue 1
Issue
Volume 21 Issue 1
Pages
685–728
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
TR