Adaleti Getiren Hayaletler: İskoç Baladlarında Kadın ve Hesaplaşma

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Ayşegül Demir
Cited by: 0
References: 9

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This article addresses a persistent assumption in ballad scholarship that supernatural return functions as a coherent form of 'poetic' or 'supernatural justice.'While Scottish ballads frequently stage posthumous visitations revealed through ghosts, betrayed lovers, or murdered children, little attention has been paid to how these returns operate through fundamentally different ethical logics, particularly in relation to gendered responsibility and accountability.Focusing on the Greig-Duncan versions of William and Margaret and The Cruel Mother (Vol.2), this study undertakes a comparative close reading at the level of individual lines, tonal shifts, and scenes of spectral speech and silence.Treating these versions as nodal texts within a broader field of oral variation, the analysis examines how supernatural intervention displaces moral judgement from legal and religious institutions onto narrative and embodied spaces.The article argues that the ghost motif does not produce a single model of supernatural justice.Instead, William and Margaret and The Cruel Mother reveal sharply divergent configurations of moral reckoning.In the former, the female ghost articulates a demand for accountability that interrupts romantic betrayal narratives and exposes suppressed obligations within patriarchal promise structures.In the latter, ghostly children reinforce an internalized regime of shame and discipline, intensifying normative expectations of womanhood rather than unsettling them.By combining Cultural Materialism with feminist criticism, the study demonstrates that Scottish supernatural ballads function as narrative sites where gendered systems of justice are negotiated in the absence of effective institutional authority.The ghosts do not restore harmony, they make visible the contradictions, exclusions, and uneven moral expectations embedded in gendered social orders.* AI-assisted tools were used for the English translation and language editing of this article; the conceptual framework, analysis, and all interpretations were developed by the author.Bu makalenin İngilizce çeviri ve dilsel düzenleme sürecinde yapay zekâ tabanlı araçlardan yararlanılmış; kuramsal çerçeve, analiz ve tüm yorumlar yazara ait olarak oluşturulmuştur.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Folklore Mythology and Literature Studies Scottish History and National Identity Historical Literary and Cultural Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
Turkish Studies - Language and Literature
Volume
Volume 21 Issue 1
Issue
Volume 21 Issue 1
Pages
729–764
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
TR