A distância de erro, nova via para a avaliação da capacidade de localização de enclaves:: ensaio de aplicação num projeto de intervenção educativa junto de alunos do terceiro ano do Ensino Secundário Obrigatório

Read full text
Authors: Jaume Binimelis Sebastián, Antoni Pons Esteva, Alejandro Gómez Gonçalves, Gabriel Mateu Janer
Cited by: 0

Abstract

This study, which follows a quasi-experimental design, analyzes the impact of a didactic intervention on the capacity of correct geographic location (place location knowledge) among students in the third year of compulsory secondary education. Eight schools in the Balearic Islands participated, with pre- and post-tests administered through a digital tool that assessed both the traditional correct/incorrect system and the distance in kilometers between the selected and actual locations. Data from 223 students who completed both tests were analyzed. The intervention, implemented in the pilot schools, was based on activities using interrelated maps. Statistical analysis included mixed ANOVAs and Spearman correlations to evaluate error patterns. Results indicate that spatial accuracy depends on geographic factors (latitude, border effect) and cognitive factors (Eurocentric bias, media presence). Moreover, measuring error distance reveals improvements not captured by the dichotomous approach. The intervention increased absolute accuracy but did not significantly reduce relative error among those who failed both tests, suggesting that map-comparison tasks foster nominal recognition and memorization rather than deep spatial skills. The study concludes that combining absolute and relative metrics enriches interpretation and informs the design of more effective teaching strategies.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Geography Education and Pedagogy Spatial Cognition and Navigation Geography and Education Methods

Publication details

Journal / source
Scientific Repository of Open Access of Portugal (RCAAP)
Publication date
1 February 2026
Language
ES