Mark Campbell‑Roddis – Submission to UK Parliament & Ministry of Defence on the Chaotic Withdrawal from Afghanistan and Failings in UK Military Strategy (August 2021)

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Mark Campbell-Roddis
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Publication date: March 2026 ---------------- Originally Submitted: August 2021 -------------------- Abstract -------- This record contains Dr Mark Campbell‑Roddis’ August 2021 submission to the UK Parliament and Ministry of Defence criticising the chaotic withdrawal from Afghanistan and the broader failures of UK military strategy in the country. It also includes earlier material: published warnings in the UK press (2010–2011) and private submissions to Parliament and Government (2014–2015) concerning the deteriorating UK and Allied intervention in Afghanistan. Purpose of Publication ---------------------- This submission is published now, five years on, in 2026, to contribute to informed debate on strategic decision‑making in UK Defence and Foreign Policy, and to document my contemporaneous thinking for the historical record. This document is being released as part of a structured effort to place my historic defence correspondence into the public domain in an accurate, verifiable, and responsibly redacted form. Sufficient time has now passed since the original 2021 submission for the concerns raised to have been considered and addressed by UK Government. Publishing now ensures that the warnings, analysis, and proposals it contains are preserved in their original form and cannot be lost, misrepresented, selectively quoted, or misappropriated by others. Its release forms part of a wider archival project documenting my correspondence with UK Government and Parliament on strategic decision‑making in UK Defence and Foreign Policy. Making this material openly accessible supports historical research, policy scrutiny, and public understanding, while providing a clear and traceable record of my professional contributions for my family and for future generations. The UK Ministry of Defence & Foreign Office receive substantial public funding. In return, they must be able to accommodate informed criticism while respecting freedom of expression — particularly where the aim is to improve future decision‑making and performance. This publication is made in that spirit. I sincerely hope that lesson has been learned. Note on Confidentiality Markings -------------------------------- The confidentiality markings throughout this document were applied by me in 2021 as a courtesy to the closed review process. They do not reflect any government classification. They are preserved here solely for historical accuracy. MARK CAMPBELL‑RODDIS Dunblane, Perthshire March 2026 © Mark Campbell‑Roddis 2026.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Politics and Conflicts in Afghanistan Pakistan and Middle East Military History and Strategy Defense Military and Policy Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
Publication date
18 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint