Impacts and effects of external school evaluation: from school performance to teachers and leaders perceptions

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Georgina Florbela Fernandes Dinis de Campos Lopes
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This work is part of the project Mechanisms of change in schools and inspection. A study on the 3rd cycle of External Evaluation of Schools in Non-Higher Education in Portugal (MAEE) - PTDC/CED-EDG/30410/2017 and includes two studies. The docu-mentary analysis study aimed to assess school performance following changes in the third cycle of External School Evaluation (AEE) in 148 school reports available nation-wide until the end of December 2022 on the IGEC website. These reports were consulted based on the classification obtained by each school in the areas assessed in the third cy-cle of the AEE (Self-assessment, Leadership and Management, Provision of Educational Services and Results). The results show identical ratings for public, private and coopera-tive education, with a predominance of Good, followed by Very Good for the areas of Results and Provision of Educational Services, with these levels being reversed in the case of Leadership and Management. In the area of Self-Assessment, Good is the most frequent rating, followed by Sufficient. The case study carried out in a school cluster in the Central Region aimed to ascertain the degree of satisfaction of teachers and leaders with the AEE process and their percep-tion of the effects in the different domains included in the reference framework of the 3rd evaluation cycle, as well as to identify the mechanisms of change resulting from the ex-ternal evaluation. To this end, a questionnaire survey was used, with 60 teachers and 37 leaders responding, and an interview was also conducted with the school group's man-agement.In general, the data reveal overall satisfaction with the AEE and a perception of medium-level effects, with a higher percentage in the areas of Self-assessment, Leadership and Management, and Results, reaching a higher percentage at the high level in the area of Educational Service Provision. Both the level of satisfaction and the effects are felt more by leaders than by teachers. Regarding the mechanisms of change involved in the trans-formation of the school resulting from the AEE, the dimension related to the use of feedback stands out, followed by the dimension of acceptance of feedback. However, there is also the possibility of less desirable effects occurring, which require attention from the external evaluation teams.Keywords: external evaluation of schools, school performance, teachers and leadership, impact and effects, mechanisms for change.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Educational Assessment and Improvement Education and Public Policy Evaluation of Teaching Practices

Publication details

Journal / source
Portuguese National Funding Agency for Science, Research and Technology (RCAAP Project by FCT)
Publication date
20 February 2026
Language
PT
Document type
Thesis