Abstract
‘[T]he decision, if there is to be one, must advance toward a future which is not known, which cannot be anticipated.’ - Derrida Portrait de la Jeune Fille en Feu (Celine Sciamma, dir. 2019) is animated by portraiture’s production of images. Soliciting allegory, extant criticism principally addresses its lesbian replay of the ‘poet’s choice’ in Orpheus and Eurydice. My paper, however, alights on the depiction of abortion. While the central portrait is commissioned to contract a marriage emblematising the ‘reproductive futurism’ of Lee Edelman’s now seminal work, the lovers – painter and painted subject – not only help a maid secure her abortion but Heloise insists that Marianne sketches that scene. Doing so, Marianne substitutes the abortionist’s face for that of her lover. In 2009 Jennifer Doyle countered No Future (2004) by proposing that rather than the ‘sinthomosexual,’ the ‘body standing in the way of reproduction, futurity, and life itself is quite specifically that of the abortive woman.’ She then indicated the extreme difficulty in making that argument within the American university – her one untouchable subject (an almost quaint point in our embattled times). Doyle’s excavation of a feminist archive on abortion disregarded by Edelman – even as the inflammatory imagery of the US anti-abortion lobby provided him with a key figure – sparks this paper. Edelman, Doyle reports, glosses only the most ‘accessible’ argument made by Barbara Johnson in 1986 regarding the personification of the fetus. While Doyle wonders why No Future disregarded her ‘figural identification of feminist authorship with infanticide,’ I alight on an incipiently Derridean path in ‘Apostrophe, Animation, and Abortion.’ There, Johnson wrote that 'It is often said, in literary-theoretical circles, that to focus on undecidability is to be apolitical. […] on the contrary, the undecidable is the political. There is politics precisely because there is undecidability. And there is also poetry.' There is politics because there is undecidability and there is poetry. Movements defending abortion tend not to self-name as pro-abortion, but as the more palatable pro-choice rightfully exercised by individuals in possession of ‘bodily autonomy.’ Beholden to ‘strategic’ essentialism, I align with such petitioners before the law. But a wholly other thought was opened by Canadian philosopher-poet Karen Houle in 2007. Eschewing the liberal ideal of autonomy, displacing choice with decision, Houle invites Derrida to pause upon the Mount Moriah of abortion. In the firelight of the impasse of responsibility he identified in The Gift of Death as ‘the most common thing,’ Houle insists on the most common experience of abortion consequent upon unwelcome pregnancy as of core concern to ethics. The unwelcome pregnancy unaccompanied by any ‘justificatory’ story of coercion characterizes the highly unusual minor narrative of Portrait de la Jeune Fille en Feu: the maid’s abortion. Yet among the film’s numerous ‘secret’ paintings, the sketch of Heloise nevertheless burns away at the contractual calculation of the formal portrait. Edelman held ‘reproductive futurism’ to characterise narrative as such and thus no identity lead revolt could abort it. By means of the iterative image-making of Portrait together with the work of Johnson, Houle and Derrida, this paper kindles a poeisis that does not fire futurity but conditions it otherwise.