Authors:
Tamás Nagy, Violeta Enea, Sophia Christin Weissgerber, Linda Geven, Rizqy Amelia Zein, Mariia M. Ostroha, Feyza Topçu, Fitri Ariyanti Abidin, Erin Michelle Buchanan, Kareena McAloney-Kocaman, Kristel Mikkor, Burcu Tekeş
+88 more
Zoe M. Flack, Oliver Lindemann, Balazs Aczel, Samuel P. Hills, Ho Yan Lai, Theresa Elise Wege, Grace McMahon, Suzanna Forwood, Deborah Crossland, Jenny Terry, Merve Gülçin Tutlu, Christina Artemenko, Michael Batashvili, Jonas De keersmaecker, Gabriel Baník, Juneman Abraham, Daniel Ansari, Ratna Jatnika, Gabriella Daróczy, Wing Yee Cheung, James M. Clay, Lucy Victoria Justice, Zoe Leviston, Ivan Ropovik, Mahmoud Elsherif, Bruno Verschuère, Samuel G. Penny, Saadet Yapan, Ilija Z. Milovanović, Kristel De Groot, Kinga Morsanyi, Zsófia K. Takács, Hans‐Christoph Nuerk, Felix Oromena Egara, Patricia Garrido‐Vásquez, Andy Field, Alyssa Counsell, Yiyun Shou, Karin Täht, Stefan Agrigoroaei, Anne H. van Hoogmoed, Samantha K. Stanley, Mauricio Salgado, Darcy Hallett, Olena V. Semenikhina, Desirée González, Tessa R. Flack, Katharina Schmid, Elise Grimm, Dimitri Löchner, Frank Scharnowski, Tolga Ergiyen, Leona Cilar, Flavia Heloisa Santos, Martin James Barwood, Stephanie N.L. Schmidt, Omid Ghasemi, Matthew Brolly, Alejandro J. Estudillo, Maria Flakus, Jordan Randell, Joanna Lewis, Jacob Owusu Sarfo, Jodie E. Chapman, Mauricio Garrido, Skylar Taylor, Patrick Aaron O'Connor, Joel H. Anderson, Siobhán M. Griffin, Nicholas A. Badcock, Nicola Palena, Darren Rhodes, Iro Xenidou‐Dervou, Johnrev Guilaran, Lee T. Copping, Robert M Ross, Conal Monaghan, Crystal Nicole Steltenpohl, Andrea Greco, Nazlı Akay, Anke Caroline Büttner, Lisa A. D. Webster, Kalu T. U. Ogba, Angélica Polvani Trassi, Argiro Vatakis, Andras Norbert Zsido, Oliver James Clark, Shane Lindsay
Cited by:
0
Abstract
Statistics anxiety is widely recognised as a barrier to student learning, and the Statistics Anxiety Rating Scale (STARS) is its most widely used self-report measure. However, it remains unclear whether the STARS captures a construct distinct from mathematics anxiety or reflects a jangle fallacy. Using a large international sample of undergraduate students (N = 6,885) from 83 universities across 33 countries, we examined the empirical distinctiveness of the STARS relative to the Revised Mathematics Anxiety Rating Scale (R-MARS). Across four criteria, the evidence indicated substantial overlap. First, correlations between the STARS and R-MARS were consistently strong. Second, exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses showed that items clustered primarily by type of educational experience (e.g., tests, help-seeking, interpretation) rather than by domain, with limited and unstable domain-specific factors. Third, both scales demonstrated statistically equivalent associations with 11 theoretically related anxiety and education variables. Fourth, the R-MARS explained negligible incremental variance beyond the STARS across these outcomes. Together, the findings suggest that the STARS and R-MARS largely measure the same underlying construct. Their continued separate use risks redundancy, conceptual fragmentation, and statistical artefacts, underscoring the need for clearer construct definition and more precise measurement tools.