Abstract
Forensic science is one of the most useful tools to help a jury determine a verdict. Forensic evidence presented by the prosecution, including fingerprint analysis, hair analysis, bite mark analysis, and DNA, has led to numerous convictions for violent felony crimes, including rape and murder. However, forensic techniques that were developed decades ago, and sometimes still in use, are not as reliable as originally thought. When forensic evidence is introduced at trial, expert witnesses are needed to provide interpretations for the jury to aid their decision making. However, the forensic evidence is open to subjective interpretation, meaning that the testimony could be faulty. Faulty forensic science, such as invalid bite mark analysis, has led to wrongful convictions. Furthermore, confident experts are typically viewed as credible and trustworthy (Martire et al., 2020), even if the testimony they deliver is invalid. The complexity of expert testimony may also persuade juries. Overall, juries may be persuaded by faulty complex forensic science delivered by a confident expert (Koehler, 2020). However, Mitchell and Garrett (2020) argue that a defense expert rebuttal could make jurors aware of the inconsistencies and errors associated with forensic evidence, increasing the likelihood that jurors will take into account other trial evidence and not rely on faulty science. Because of faulty scientific testimony, people are convicted of crimes they did not commit. Furthermore, invalid testimony could lead to the overturn of a conviction for someone who did the crime they were accused of. Either way, expert witness testimony is held in high regard and could be the tipping point from one verdict to another, especially when the testimony is covering forensic analysis that can be interpreted differently, depending on the examiner. My study aims to look at how the complexity of an expert’s faulty forensic testimony, along with the presence of a defense expert rebuttal, affects jurors’ decision making. The purpose of my research is to not only determine how expert testimony presentation affects juror decision making, but also show which ways of presenting testimony will result in the correct, just verdict. Participants will read testimony from a prosecutor’s expert witness; this expert will present faulty forensic science testimony, either set at a high or low level of complexity; next, participants will either be exposed to a defensive expert witness rebuttal or not. The study will evaluate which factors affect the jurors’ decisions on guilt, assessing further how the characteristics of an expert and the complexity of the information provided will affect the outcome of a trial. It is hypothesized that expert testimony with a lower level of complexity and the presence of a defense rebuttal will increase the likelihood of a correct not guilty verdict. It is additionally hypothesized that faulty expert testimony delivered with high complexity and no defense rebuttal will lead to an increase in guilty verdicts. Overall, this study aims to determine how jurors’ perceptions of an expert witness affect their decisions.