Exploring The Realm of Legionella in Water Heaters: Hormetic Copper, Antagonistic Neochlamydia, Holistic Insulation and Protective Sediment

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Fernando A. Roman
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Opportunistic premise plumbing pathogens (OPPPs), including Legionella pneumophila and Mycobacterium avium, are increasingly associated with waterborne disease outbreaks in the United States. Despite their rising prominence, several factors influencing the growth and mitigation of Legionella and other OPPPs, such as pipe materials, microbial ecology, temperature gradients, water heater configuration, and the role of sediment are poorly understood. This dissertation sheds light on the role of these factors using complementary microcosm and pilot-scale experiments to examine effects of various control strategies on OPPP growth. Chapter 2 investigates how copper (0–2000 µg/L) impacted L. pneumophila and M. avium over an 11-month period using microcosms to simulate warm premise plumbing conditions. Copper was confirmed to have a hormetic effect, acting as a nutrient at low levels and an antimicrobial at high levels. At an intermediate copper dose of 250 μg/L, M. avium and total cell counts peaked in concentration, whereas the impact of copper on L. pneumophila at this dosage was stochastic amongst replicates. Comparatively, 2000 μg/L of copper suppressed M. avium, L. pneumophila, and total cell counts, though total cell counts steadily rebounded at this dosage throughout the entire experiment Chapter 3 closely examined the stochastic behavior of L. pneumophila in microcosms. A retrospective analysis on the copper-dosed microcosms described above and an earlier study of conditions leading to the Flint Water Crisis Legionnaires' Disease outbreak reveals a potential antagonistic relationship between Neochlamydia and L. pneumophila. This is consistent with prior evidence from pure culture studies that amoebae harboring Neochlamydia are resistant to L. pneumophila infection. The background water chemistry and pipe materials can influence the outcome of the competition between Neochlamydia and Legionella, suggesting probiotic approaches for OPPP control are already naturally occurring in some buildings. Two chapters of the dissertation focus on full scale experiments in residential water heaters. In chapter 4 recirculating, standard, and on-demand (tankless) water heater configurations were operated and evaluated for delivered hot-water temperatures, internal thermal profiles, energy efficiency, and volumes of water within temperature ranges at risk for Legionella growth. At a setpoint of 48°C, the recirculating configuration had the lowest energy efficiency and the highest volume of water at risk for Legionella growth, whereas at 66° C the standard tank had highest growth risk. Adding extra insulation to standard electric water heaters could eliminate Legionella growth habitat while reducing heat loss--a holistic approach to improving environmental sustainability and public health. Although thermal control is widely recommended for Legionella mitigation, chapter 5 reveals important limitations to the approach. Experiments using a typical 40-gallon residential water heater demonstrated that sediment, which can naturally accumulate at the bottom of water heater tanks, created dead space with temperatures that cooled with sediment depth. Even when the bulk water in the tank was completely mixed and the bulk water temperatures were ≥55–60 °C, portions of the sediment were cooler and permissive for Legionella growth. Two distinct mechanisms were responsible for cooling the sediment and its associated dead space: contact of the bottom of the tank with a relatively cold floor and settling of cold influent water. The sediment also increased the available surface area by several orders of magnitude compared to the internal surface area of the water heater. The cooler temperatures and high surface area could create extraordinary pathogen growth potential that causes culturable and molecularly detectable L. pneumophila to persist indefinitely. Use of external insulation between the tank and the floor can sometimes heat the sediment to a point that could eliminate Legionella growth. Chapter 6 is a Viewpoint that examines the interplay of truth, trust, and utility practices in pre-venting waterborne disease outbreaks by shaping water quality before it enters buildings to re-duce Legionnaires' Disease risk. For instance, infrastructure upgrades and improved treatment can increase disinfectant residuals and reduce sediment in supply waters, honoring a utilities to the social contract with their customers. We argue that continued denial and deception associated with this responsibility will lead to distrust and disinvestment, similar to that which arose from past failures to deal with health treats from lead contamination due to corrosive water. The overall dissertation illustrates how OPPP and L. pneumophila control in premise plumbing is influenced by ecological and engineering factors, including water chemistry, microbial inter-actions, temperature gradients, sediment and water heater design. These novel findings help explain why previously recommended mitigation strategies may not always suppress L. pneumophila in buildings and highlight the need for holistic control approaches targeting worst case niches in which Legionella can thrive.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Legionella and Acanthamoeba research Water Treatment and Disinfection Mycobacterium research and diagnosis

Publication details

Journal / source
VTechWorks (Virginia Tech)
Publication date
20 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis