An efficacy trial of Positive Early Childhood Education (PECE), a two-arm cluster randomised controlled trial

Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Thea Sofie Schei, Svetlana Speight, Ekaterina Stoilova
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

**The programme** The Positive Early Childhood Education (PECE) programme is an early years (EY) whole-setting professional development programme developed by Triple P UK (TPUK). It aims to help EY practitioners improve the way they respond to and interact with children and create environments that support children’s self-regulation and social, emotional, and behavioural development. The programme draws on social learning theory, cognitive-behavioural approaches and self-regulation frameworks, and has been adapted specifically for early childhood education and care settings. PECE teaches 22 strategies that collectively target key risks and protective factors linked to children’s long-term and social-emotional and behavioural outcomes. These are taught through two separate training programmes: a coaching course and accreditation for setting managers (PECE coaches), and a self-paced online course for all other EY practitioners (PECE educators). The components are designed to improve everyday adult-child interactions across the setting, creating consistent and supportive experiences for young children. The evaluation The evaluation of PECE is funded by the Education Endowment Foundation (EEF), with TPUK delivering the programme and the National Centre for Social Research (NatCen) carrying out the research. The trial will take place in PVI and school-based nursery settings in England. TPUK will recruit 140 settings to take part in the evaluation. In settings that are randomised to receive the programme, practitioners will take part in the TPUK training. Trained educators will then be able to use the PECE approaches with the 3-4-year-old children at their settings, with coaches providing ongoing support. In settings randomised to the control group, staff will carry on with their usual practice. The programme will be delivered in the 2026-2027 school year, from October 2026 to June 2027. There will be two evaluation reports: the main evaluation report using data collected during the trial will be published in spring 2027, and a follow-up report using data matched from the National Pupil Database will be published in autumn 2029. Impact Evaluation The impact evaluation (IE) of the PECE training programme will aim to answer the following primary research question: RQ1: Does the PECE programme improve 3–4-year-olds' self-regulation, as reported by EY practitioners? The IE will be conducted as a two-arm cluster randomised controlled efficacy trial, with settings as the unit of randomisation and children as the unit of analysis. A total of 140 settings will be recruited and randomised into two trial arms: the PECE programme and practice as usual (PAU) comparison group. We will randomise at the setting level, as the programme delivery targets practitioners, and all children within a setting are expected to be exposed to PECE-trained practitioners. Randomisation of settings will be stratified by region, setting type (i.e. PVI and school-based nurseries) and Income Deprivation Affecting Children Index (IDACI) score, to ensure balance of these characteristics between PECE and control settings. Financial incentives will be provided to settings allocated to the comparison group for participating in data collection activities. Additional incentives will be provided to practitioners in all settings for participating in endline data collection. The primary outcome investigated is child self-regulation (practitioner report), as measured with the Child Self-Regulation & Behaviour Questionnaire (CSBQ), combined average score of the cognitive, behavioural, and emotional self-regulation subscales (Howard and Melhuish, 2017). Secondary child-level outcomes that will be investigated include: Child prosocial behaviour (EY practitioner report) Child externalising behaviour problems (EY practitioner report) Child self-regulation (task-based measure conducted by independent test administrators) Child personal, social and emotional development and school readiness in reception year EY practitioners’ self-reported knowledge, confidence and skills in supporting child self-regulation Implementation and Process Evaluation The Implementation and process evaluation (IPE) will take a mixed-method approach to data collection and include observations, in-depth interviews, surveys, and collection of monitoring and cost data. A key element of the IPE is in-person visits to six intervention group settings. These will involve observations of practice sessions where coaches observe educators in the classroom and provide feedback, followed by interviews with the coach and/or educator. The IPE will also include an interview with the delivery team and a focus group with TPUK implementation consultants who support coaches to embed the training within their setting. The IPE will aim to answer the following research questions: RQ8: How is the programme different to usual practice? RQ9: To what extent is the programme delivered as intended? RQ10: What are the facilitators and barriers to the delivery of the programme? RQ11: What are the perceived outcomes of the programme for EY practitioners, including their knowledge, confidence and self-regulatory skills? RQ11a: Are there any differences in outcomes for those EY practitioners who are coaches vs those that are educators? RQ12: What are the perceived outcomes of the programme for children, including for their emotional and behavioural self-regulation? RQ12a: Are there any perceived outcomes of the programme on children’s behaviour and pro-social skills? RQ12b: Are there any differences in outcomes for children from disadvantaged backgrounds? RQ13: What are the perceived outcomes of the programme at the setting level? RQ13a: Are there any differences in outcomes between school-based and PVI settings? RQ14: What is the per-child cost of the programme? Ethics NatCen’s Research Ethics Committee (REC) reviewed and approved NatCen’s research proposal for this project in February 2026. NatCen’s ethics procedure is aligned with the 2021 Government Social Research (GSR) professional guidance and the 2021 Social Research Association (SRA) ethics guidance.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Early Childhood Education and Development Child and Adolescent Psychosocial and Emotional Development Behavioral and Psychological Studies

Publication details

Journal / source
OSF Preprints (OSF Preprints)
Publication date
24 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Preprint