When Real Crimes Become Entertainment : Public Interpretations of Morality and Credibility in Dramatized True Crime

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Elin Jägstrand, Melvin Greek Lagerkvist
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

In recent years, true crime has gained popularity, especially among young adults. Thegenre often blends real-life criminal cases with cinematic storytelling to reach and engagetheir audience. This mixing of both fact and fiction can lead to the line between themgetting blurred. As more productions choose to portray real life criminals and crimesthrough scripted films and series, we are forced to confront questions about authenticity,ethics, and how audiences interpret what they see.This study wants to explore how young adults, ages 20-25, interpret dramatized truecrime, and how they think about the gap between the real life criminal and their “onscreen” counterpart. The study focuses on how the audience handles questions aboutjudgement, morality, and the line between reality and fiction. To do this the study uses aqualitative approach rooted in social constructivism, where the core material stems fromfour focus group interviews containing a total of 19 young adults that regularly consumetrue crime. The interviews were recorded and later analyzed through a thematic lens torecognize the themes discussed earlier.What the study finds is that while participants know these shows are produced forentertainment, their critical thinking was situational. If a series or movie had an engagingstory, a high production value, or well-acted characters the viewers could suspend theirskepticism and sometimes even accept dramatized elements as factual. The study alsoshows that even though the participants were aware of the ethics in feeling empathytowards violent criminals, they admitted to feeling said empathy if provided an emotionalbackstory. Throughout the group discussion, the participants negotiated and reshapedtheir moral stance, which in turn shows that these stances weren’t set in stone.In conclusion, the study suggests that young adults are actively processing and discussingthemes of authenticity and morality through dramatized true crime stories rather than justpassively consuming them. The study also shows that true crime isn’t just entertainment;it serves as a type of social space wherein young adults can reflect questions of justice,responsibility, and human nature. By highlighting this, the study contributes to a deeperunderstanding of how dramatized crime is socially constructed in contemporary culture,as well as shining a light on a not so vastly explored subject.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Radio Podcasts and Digital Media Crime Deviance and Social Control Ethics Aesthetics and Art

Publication details

Journal / source
DiVA (Linnaeus University)
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
SV
Document type
Thesis