Exploring the Emotion Work of Residential Childcare Practitioners: A Feminist, Qualitative Study

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Bethany Jay
Cited by: 0
References: 533

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

This study explores the emotion work of residential childcare practitioners in England and Scotland. Emotion work is the management of internal feeling and external emotional display in professional and personal relations and goes beyond the concept of ‘emotional labour’, which considers emotion management as a workplace performance acted for financial and occupational reasons only. Emotion work is much more relevant to the role of residential childcare practitioners because their job role is fundamentally relational; practitioners’ do their work for philanthropic, as well as financial, reasons. Hence, practitioners do their emotion management for philanthropic, and financial, reasons also. There is a growing need to further understand the work of residential childcare practitioners, employed to support children in care, as research and evidence in the field tends to (understandably) focus on the experiences of children in residential care. Therefore, this study focuses on the experiences of the workforce and employs a qualitative multimethodology, reinforced by feminist standpoint theory, centring data collection around practitioners’ voices. Utilising two data collection methods, audio dairies and semi-structured interviews, sixteen residential childcare practitioners reflected on their emotional experiences at work in residential children’s homes. Through reflexive thematic analysis, I found that practitioners purposefully and relationally displayed authentic and inauthentic emotions at work. This included performances of deep acting and surface acting, and displays of authentic emotions and diluted, authentic emotions. I situate these displays of emotions on a continuum of authentic to inauthentic emotion work. Practitioners were managing their emotions and emotional displays to minimise any potential re-traumatisation of young people, alongside performing emotion management to maintain appropriateness and professionalism at work. Thus, I consider practitioner emotion work to be trauma-informed and was performed to preserve the principles of trauma-informed practice set out in the UK. However, trauma-informed care is applied with an appreciation for feminist critical perspectives regarding this approach. Moreover, my analysis found that working as a residential childcare practitioner took an immense personal, professional and physical toll on practitioner wellbeing, and highlights the need for genuine, organisational, and appropriate coping mechanisms that meet practitioners’ emotional support needs to 3 reduce burnout and turnover. The continuum of practitioner emotion work I developed offers an original contribution to knowledge and includes an emotion management tool used by practitioners that is novel within the residential childcare context: diluted emotional displays. This is when practitioners display the emotions they are truly feeling, but to a lesser degree or extent; the severity of their emotions are watered down when displayed. Overall, this research helps us better understand the emotional experiences and impact of working in residential childcare and can contribute findings to help improve working conditions that subsequently improve the quality-of-care care experienced children and young people receive.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Emotional Labor in Professions Social Work Education and Practice Child Welfare and Adoption

Publication details

Journal / source
e-space (Manchester Metropolitan University)
Publication date
24 March 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis