Bewijs in burgerrechtelijke discriminatiezaken

Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Michelle Schouteden
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Discrimination in the provision of goods and services is widespread in practice but appears relatively rarely in case law. Several recent research reports show that individuals who seek to enforce the protection afforded by anti-discrimination law before national courts encounter significant evidentiary difficulties. The same applies to parties accused of discrimination who must defend themselves against such allegations. First, anti-discrimination legislation does not clearly determine which party must prove which facts (the burden of proof). Second, questions arise regarding the degree of persuasiveness with which such proof must be established (the standard of proof). Third, uncertainty persists as to which evidentiary means and methods may be used, and in particular how far parties may go in collecting evidence. Although the general law of evidence offers potentially valuable solutions for each of these issues, it is equally unclear to what extent it may operate as a supplementary framework. Moreover, these evidentiary tools remain underutilised in anti-discrimination practice. These factors lead to an unbalanced enforcement of Belgian anti-discrimination law, with the proverbial pendulum still swinging too far in one direction or the other. This dissertation (and, more broadly, the FWO PENDL project (G078520N) within which it is situated) aims to address this imbalance by complementing the specific approach of anti-discrimination law with the insights of the general law of evidence. The dissertation is structured in four parts and consistently distinguishes between the claim seeking a declaration of discrimination and the claim seeking damages. Part I provides an overview of the applicable rules of evidence under both anti-discrimination law and the general law of evidence. By analysing the relevant conflict rules, the dissertation examines the extent to which the general law of evidence may apply in a supplementary manner. With regard to the admissibility and probative value of evidence, the answer proved straightforward: the general law of evidence applies in full. However, further research proved necessary regarding the burden of proof, the standard of proof, and the lawfulness of evidence. These issues are addressed respectively in Parts II, III, and IV of the dissertation. In Part II, the dissertation identifies four possible scenarios in which parties in a discrimination case may find themselves. For each scenario, the study delineates the respective burdens of allegation, contestation and proof. The research further identifies three factual elements that must be alleged (and subsequently may be contested and/or proven), based on the legal definitions of direct and indirect discrimination. In addition, the dissertation demonstrates how evidentiary doctrines — such as the duty to cooperate in the taking of evidence and judicial reversals of the burden of proof — can be used to mitigate the sometimes demanding evidentiary burden placed on both parties. Part III identifies the standard of proof with which each party must comply (depending on the scenario that arises) and examines the possibility of lowering that standard in exceptional circumstances. An important research finding is that the accommodation provided by anti-discrimination legislation for victims should be understood as a lowering of the standard of proof rather than as a reversal of the burden of proof. Part IV examines how both parties may lawfully collect evidentiary material in order to discharge their burden of proof. In this regard, the dissertation conducts an in-depth analysis of the Antigoon case law and demonstrates that its application may offer a valuable solution in situations involving unlawful evidence. On the basis of these research findings, the dissertation introduces a new theoretical framework for evidentiary issues. This framework includes a schematic and multi-step analytical model that can be directly applied by judges and litigating parties in civil discrimination cases. By way of conclusion, the dissertation also offers a cautious proposal to reformulate the ambiguously drafted evidentiary provision in Belgian anti-discrimination legislation. Because the proposed framework intrinsically balances the interests of both parties, it has the potential to bring the proverbial pendulum back closer to the centre.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Discrimination and Equality Law Legal processes and jurisprudence Conflict of Laws and Jurisdiction

Publication details

Journal / source
Lirias
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
EN
Document type
Thesis