preprint OISI26 7 native1 - Artefact-Induced Theorising: A Recursive Model of Native Theory Emergence in Information Systems

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: Gianni Jacucci
Cited by: 0
References: 13

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Debates on “native theory” in Information Systems (IS) have largely focused on disciplinary origin—whether theories are invented within IS or borrowed from reference disciplines. This paper reframes the debate by proposing artefact-constitutiveness, rather than provenance, as the defining criterion of nativeness. We argue that native IS theory emerges when digital artefacts become ontologically constitutive of institutional action itself, such that the explanatory mechanism collapses if programmable mediation is removed. Building on a longitudinal reconstruction of eight theory episodes spanning more than three decades of socio-technical research, we identify a dual mechanism of theory formation: (1) artefact-induced ontological pressure generated by formalisation, traceability, recursion, and programmable mediation; and (2) autopoietic selection within research communities that stabilises certain perturbations into coherent theoretical trajectories. The analysis reveals a progressive intensification of artefact-constitutiveness, as digital systems evolve from configurable tools to epistemic scaffolds and institutional infrastructures. By shifting the focus from disciplinary origin to artefact-constitutive ontology and community-level reflexivity, the paper advances a structural account of native IS theory formation. The argumentpositions IS as a paradigmatic site for studying theory emergence under computational conditions and contributes a reflexive model of theory development in the digital age.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Information Systems Theories and Implementation Scientific Research and Philosophical Inquiry Cybernetics and Technology in Society

Publication details

Journal / source
AIS Electronic Library (AISeL)
Publication date
29 March 2026
Language
EN