Dam Failure Probability and Direct Economic Risk Analysis Based on Defect Detection and Numerical Simulation

Read full text Summarise with VIRAT
Authors: HOU Bochao, Chen Jialei, Song Lixiang
Cited by: 0

Summary

No summary yet. VIRAT can read this paper and write a plain-language summary of its aim, methods, key findings and limitations.

Summarise with VIRAT Free to try with your Science Catalogs account.

Abstract

Accurately estimating the probability and consequences of low-probability, catastrophic events such as dam failure remains a critical challenge. Existing studies on dam failure probability often insufficiently account for actual defects within the dam body and involve considerable subjectivity in assigning probabilities to basic events, leading to deviations between calculated and actual failure probabilities. Furthermore, few studies have integrated probability calculations with economic loss assessments to achieve a comprehensive quantitative evaluation of reservoir dam failure risk. Taking Nanshui Reservoir as the study object, two major categories comprising seven failure paths were established based on the event tree method. To reduce subjectivity in probability assignment, triangular fuzzy numbers were introduced to represent the probability of key failure stages along each path, and defect detection indicators were used to determine the optimism coefficients in fuzzy number quantification, enabling precise failure probability estimation. A coupled one-dimensional river channel–two-dimensional surface hydrodynamic model for the downstream area was constructed using the HydroMPM model cloud platform and calibrated with water level and discharge data from the June 2022 flood event. The DL BREACH model was employed to simulate flood inundation processes under 15 dam failure scenarios across the seven failure paths. Direct economic losses were quantified using depth–loss rate curves, and direct economic risk was comprehensively evaluated within the "risk = probability × consequences" framework. The results indicate that: ①Most structural indicators of Nanshui Reservoir are normal, with only localized voids or cracks in certain areas. Except for Path 3, the optimism coefficients for all other paths exceed 0.6, reflecting the dam's overall good condition.②The comprehensive dam failure probability of Nanshui Reservoir is 2.00 × 10⁻⁵, significantly lower than the historical annual average dam failure rate for reservoirs in China, indicating a high level of overall safety. Among the seven failure paths, Path 1 (overtopping due to dam settlement) exhibits the highest probability at 6.43 × 10⁻⁶. ③ Under the same failure mode, inundation area increases with flood return period, but the variation across different return periods is generally within 20%. The inundation extent from overtopping failure is significantly larger than that from piping failure, with Path 2 (overtopping caused by flood discharge facility failure) producing the largest inundation area. ④Direct economic losses from dam failure at Nanshui Reservoir all exceed 2 billion yuan, and the direct economic risk in the downstream area is 58,743.17 yuan. Analysis indicates that high-return-period (1000-year and 5000-year) loading conditions contribute the most to overall risk, suggesting that priority should be given to preventing extreme flood or earthquake events. This study provides a systematic and quantifiable new framework for dam failure probability and risk assessment.

Fields of Study & Subjects

Dam Engineering and Safety Flood Risk Assessment and Management Water resources management and optimization

Publication details

Journal / source
DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals)
Publication date
1 January 2026
Language
ZH